Sooner or later, every discussion of K-12 education gets around to the "kids
these days" issue. Today's children seem to be on average less respectful of
authority, more inclined to disruptive behavior, harder to motivate and generally bereft
of deep grounding in the values that undergird the educational process. Some
apologists for traditional public education claim that schools are being asked to
compensate for what parents have failed to do to prepare their children for learning.
Some advocates for private school vouchers say the ability of private schools to
explicitly base instruction on religious values are the key to their superiority to public
schools in educational results.
But there is now a growing movement to take bullish kids by the horns: to make the
basic character virtues most critical to learning -- honesty, courtesy, tolerance, personal
responsibility, openness to new information, acceptance of authority, respect for
achievement, ability to delay gratification, and so on -- central to the organization of
schools and their curricula.
The "character education" movement has received its biggest boost in
Maryland, where Lieutenant Governor Kathleen Kennedy Townsend has spearheaded
an initiative to make instruction in, and embodiment of, the "civic virtues" a
basic feature of daily life in every public school. In an article in the November/December
1997 issue of The New Democrat, Townsend cited national studies
showing that character education initiatives have reduced disciplinary problems,
truancy, vandalism, and even teen pregnancy rates. Anticipating the argument that
character education displaces the role parents play in the moral training of their
children, she also reported that in Baltimore, not one parent of the 50,000 students
involved has objected. "The only complaint is, 'Why didn't we have this
sooner?'"
The recently released report of the National Commission for Civic Renewal has
called for widespread adoption of character education, along with instruction in U.S.
civic traditions that reflect the same values. U.S. Secretary of Education Richard Riley is
a big fan of character education, and the President praised it in recent remarks to the
American Federation of Teachers.
Does character education overburden teachers with an additional responsibility
remote from traditional education? Actually, shaping the character of children has
always been part of the mission of public education in America. Furthermore,
observance of civilized norms of behavior has always been essential to creating an
environment in which teachers can teach and students can learn.
Character education reflects the kind of values-based public policy that Americans
appear to crave, often over the objections of those on the left who oppose official
recognition of moral absolutes, and those on the right who demand official recognition
of the religious traditions in which values are rooted. If Maryland is any indication,
parents love it, it seems to work, and it's time to try it everywhere.