What is the "big idea" that is the fountainhead for the "new
ideas" New Democrats seek to develop? It's the "Third Way."
President Clinton talks about the "Third Way" often, as does the First
Lady, who thinks it offers a formulation for a new ideology that can unite Democrats.
British Prime Minister Tony Blair refers to the "Third Way" as the central
principle of his "New Labour" Party.
In short, the Third Way is becoming the global generic brand name for the
progressive politics of the Information Age. The term first came into use in 1990 as the
DLC's shorthand for the distinctive viewpoint of New Democrats. It signaled our
determination to overcome the stale left-right debate that had dominated American
politics for a generation, and to modernize the Democratic Party and the public sector
into instruments for addressing the very new problems facing the country in a new era.
For Democrats, the Third Way does not mean abandoning such
traditional progressive principles as equal opportunity, civil rights, cultural tolerance,
an active public sector, a sense of collective responsibility for our individual destinies,
or a special commitment to Americans in need. It does mean rethinking how we apply
these principles, just as progressives rethought public policies at other great turning
points in our history like the Industrial Revolution, the Great Depression, and the Civil
Rights Movement. And it does mean abandoning the recent tendency of traditional
liberals to place defense or expansion of government programs at the top of their
agenda, even if they no longer promote the goals they were originally designed to
achieve or reflect the values they were originally intended to vindicate.
While challenging the left to adjust to changing times, the Third Way also creates a
new and more vigorous intellectual and political competition for the right. For decades,
political conservatives have prospered simply by critiquing the big government
excesses and cultural eccentricities of traditional liberals. By taking away these easy
targets, the "Third Way" forces conservatives to try to articulate a positive
governing agenda, which they are currently incompetent to offer with any degree of
unity or coherence.
Most broadly, the Third Way represents an acceptance of two verdicts of history
that many on the Left have been slow to acknowledge. First, capitalism is the best
economic system yet devised for creating growth and efficiently allocating resources,
and second, two-parent families nurturing such values as faith, work, personal
responsibility, civility, and openness to new ideas are the best social unit yet devised for
raising children.
But at the same time, the Third Way represents a rejection of the right's tendency to
turn capitalism into a religion, confusing means with ends, and abandoning the public
responsibility to shape market forces to produce broad-based economic and social
progress. It also means rejecting the right's reluctance to support families and reinforce
mainstream values with public resources that give them the tools they need to do what
they do best: create opportunity, instill responsibility, and embody community.
Put it all together, and you have a new political ideology that uses market means to
pursue public goals; that combines fidelity to traditional values with a fearless
determination to shape rapid economic and technological change; and that insists on
organizing public resources for the common good while recognizing the increasing
impotence of large, centralized bureaucracies and the increasing importance of
self-governing individuals and community institutions. That means tough
environmental standards met through market-based innovations like emissions trading.
That means replacing the welfare system with a competitive employment system. That
means saving public education through choice, competition, and accountability for
measurable results. That means opening global trade while "expanding the
winner's circle" of Americans prepared with skills to participate in the blessings
of economic growth. That means every "idea of the week" we have
promoted in the DLC Update and
many more to come.
The Third Way is important not just to ideologues and intellectuals, but to elected
officials, political activists, and citizens. It shows that the "centrist" politics
of New Democrats is not located in the mushy middle of the old political spectrum,
aimed at split-the-difference compromises between liberals and conservatives in their
endless, and often pointless, battles over funding levels for existing government
programs, and their common efforts to reward constituency groups with patronage
favors and public subsidies. And it vindicates the stubborn desire of people -- not just in
America but in Europe, Latin American and Australia -- exhibited in serial rejections of
traditional political parties, for a public philosophy that transcends the old left-right
choices a stubborn desire for "a Third Way."
For a clear and thorough articulation of the Third Way, read the
New Progressive
Declaration.