DLC - Democratic Leadership Council
Democratic Leadership Council Home
Search Tips 



PrintPrintable Version of this Article

Send this Article to a FriendSend this Article to a Friend

Related Links Letter From Sen. Evan Bayh, et al., to President Bush



Ideas




Press Center
Press Releases

Office of Sen. Evan Bayh | Press Release | February 5, 2001
Bayh Wants Tax Cut With "Trigger" to Preserve Surplus
Senator leads bipartisan call for Bush to safeguard the economy, avoid deficits


For Immediate Release
Contact:
Mark Kornblau -- 202/224-5623

WASHINGTON, DC -- U.S. Senator Evan Bayh supports President Bush's call for tax cuts that will benefit all Americans and is proposing additional measures to control runaway congressional spending and ensure fiscal responsibility. Bayh has organized a bipartisan group of Senators who today proposed a "trigger" mechanism that will enable Congress to provide broad-based tax relief while avoiding a return to chronic deficits.

Joining Bayh in presenting the trigger idea to President Bush are Senators Mary Landrieu (D-LA), Arlen Specter (R-PA,) Lincoln Chafee (R-RI) and Dianne Feinstein (D-CA). The bipartisan group today sent a letter to President George W. Bush and congressional leaders endorsing the idea of a broad-based tax cut and urging them to consider a trigger mechanism. The trigger would protect against deficits and runaway spending by making future tax cuts contingent upon the realization of projected surpluses at acceptable pre-determined levels.

"This approach guarantees that all Americans share the benefit of a tax cut," Bayh said. "It also ensures that we continue to practice fiscal responsibility, balance the budget and pay down the debt. A trigger mechanism will help us avoid runaway spending and future tax increases by putting pressure on Congress to control spending or face the consequences."

"The clear advantages of this approach are that it makes tax cuts contingent upon continued fiscal discipline, and it provides a brake against runaway spending. It also renders the tremendous uncertainty implicit in the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projections much less of a problem because broad-based tax reductions would be contingent upon actual, not projected, surpluses," the group wrote.

"Most economists say they can predict economic growth with near certainty for the next 6 months, and that they will feel comfortable predicting as far as two or three years down the road," said Senator Landrieu. "However, a majority of the proposed $1.6 trillion tax cut being discussed does not kick in for at least five years, with most of the cuts coming ten years from now. A 'trigger' mechanism that ties the tax cuts to the actual surplus -- not an estimated surplus based on long range predictions -- is the only way we can be sure we are voting for fiscally responsible tax cuts."

The trigger would require that a minimum on-budget surplus remains intact at the close of each fiscal year before certain phased-in elements of a tax cut can take effect the following year. If surpluses drop below the agreed upon level, then the next increment of the tax cut would be implemented when adequate surpluses return.

Earlier this week, the CBO projected a ten-year budget surplus of $2.7 trillion (excluding Social Security and Medicare). The growing surplus estimates have led some in Congress to call for larger tax cuts. However, Bayh and his bipartisan group of moderates cautioned that surplus estimates are "fraught with uncertainty." The group pointed to 1995 CBO projections that missed the mark on the Year 2000 surplus by $578 billion. "Why not base our fiscal policy on real numbers, rather than hazy estimates?" Bayh asked.

"In our view, such a 'trigger' mechanism offers a safety valve to protect against what many senators fear: a return to deficits should economic conditions -- and budget projections -- change in the years ahead," the bipartisan letter continues. "It acknowledges the uncertainty implicit in ten-year estimates and ensures that we will not return to chronic deficits."

Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan endorsed such an approach in last week's testimony before the Senate Budget Committee. "It is important that any long-term tax plan, or spending initiative for that matter, be phased in," Greenspan said. "Conceivably, (a tax cut) could include provisions that, in some way, would limit surplus-reducing actions if specified targets for the budget surplus and federal debt were not satisfied."